Contents
About the Garmin Alpha 200 handheld with T20Alternatives at a glanceRadio or phone networkUpdate speedBattery and toughnessRunning costsThe alternativesFAQsThe Garmin Alpha 200 is a favourite with gundog and hound owners who walk in big, remote country. It is also a serious outlay, especially once you add a collar for each dog. Plenty of owners do not need radio range or a dedicated handheld, and a phone-based GPS tracker covers them well. It is a capable system. Prices vary by bundle.
This guide lists cheaper trackers worth a look and explains what you gain and give up compared with the Alpha. We only include tracking products here, nothing with a training stimulation function. We also explain where a phone tracker falls short, so you can decide whether the saving makes sense for the places you walk. The right choice depends on your dog.
About the Garmin Alpha 200 handheld with T20 tracking collar
The Garmin Alpha 200 is a rugged handheld GPS unit that tracks dogs wearing compatible Garmin collars over radio, so it does not rely on mobile phone signal. The UK bundle pairs it with a tracking-only collar. Prices vary by retailer and bundle.
Alternatives at a glance
- Garmin GPS Tracker, £113.79 save about £535.21
- Pet Silicone Silicone AirTag Collar Holder, £3.99 save about £645.01
- Apple GPS Dog Tracker, £29.00 save about £620.00
- ATUVOS GPS Dog Tracker, £12.62 save about £636.38
- Life360 Black GPS Dog Tracker, £14.99 save about £634.01
- Brown GPS Dog Tracker, £9.99 save about £639.01
- Tractive Black GPS Dog Tracker, £51.18 save about £597.82
- Pawfit Dog Activity Tracker, £54.99 save about £594.01
Radio or phone network
The Alpha uses radio between collar and handheld, so it works without phone signal. Most cheaper trackers use the mobile network. If you often walk in places with no signal, that matters a lot. If you walk where your phone works, a network tracker gives you live location for far less. Think honestly about where you walk. If most outings are in areas with mobile signal, a cheaper tracker will do the job.
Update speed
Working dog systems can update very often, which suits fast dogs. Check how often a cheaper tracker refreshes in live mode. A few seconds is good. A fast-moving dog can cover a lot of ground between updates, so a slow refresh rate makes it harder to follow them in real time. Garmin systems are known for frequent updates. Many phone trackers offer a live mode that updates every few seconds, though it drains the battery faster.
Battery and toughness
Look for long battery life, a stated waterproof rating and a secure collar mount. Big days in wet cover are hard on kit. Working dogs spend hours in wet cover, rivers and brambles, so the tracker needs to cope. Check the waterproof rating, the battery life in live mode and how firmly it attaches to the collar. A tracker that falls off in the first hedge is no use. UK owner reviews help here.
Running costs
Phone-based trackers usually need a plan. Add two years of fees to the purchase price when comparing with the Alpha. The Alpha has no monthly fees, which helps balance its high price over time. Phone-based trackers cost less to buy but charge for a plan. Work out the total over two or three years, including a tracker for each dog, before you decide. Do the maths first. Work out the figures first.
The alternatives

1.Garmin GPS Tracker
If you want closest match, start here. 11,719 buyers rate it 4.5 out of 5. £113.79, so you pay a bit more for the spec. Full details, sizes and photos are on the Garmin GPS Tracker page.
If it is not quite right, we stock plenty more premium gps trackers.

2.Pet Silicone Silicone AirTag Collar Holder
Pet Silicone Silicone AirTag Collar Holder is our pick for value. Specs worth noting: material Silicone. 1,404 buyers rate it 4.3 out of 5. £3.99, one of the cheaper options here. You can see the full specs and photos on the Pet Silicone Silicone AirTag Collar Holder page.
For Apple Locator Tracker Anti-Lost Device
If it is not quite right, we stock plenty more gps tracker collars.

3.Apple GPS Dog Tracker
Apple GPS Dog Tracker is our pick for collar built in. It averages 4.6 stars from 6,732 reviews. £29.00, one of the cheaper options here. You can see the full specs and photos on the Apple GPS Dog Tracker page.
: Tracker for Keychain
Wallet and More
There are other options in our gps dog trackers range too.

4.ATUVOS GPS Dog Tracker
ATUVOS GPS Dog Tracker is our pick for battery. Specs worth noting: pack 2 Pack. It averages 4.2 stars from 6,841 reviews. £12.62, one of the cheaper options here. You can see the full specs and photos on the ATUVOS GPS Dog Tracker page.
Tracker Bluetooth Item Finder
IOS Only
Compare it with the rest of our gps dog trackers.

5.Life360 Black GPS Dog Tracker
Life360 Black GPS Dog Tracker is our pick for for multiple dogs. Specs worth noting: colour Black. It averages 4.1 stars from 6,473 reviews. £14.99, one of the cheaper options here. You can see the full specs and photos on the Life360 Black GPS Dog Tracker page.
Keys Finder and Item Locator for Keys
Bags and More. Phone Finder. Both iOS and Android Compatible. 1-Pack
There are other options in our gps dog trackers range too.

6.Brown GPS Dog Tracker
This is the one we would point most people to for for small dogs. Specs worth noting: colour Brown. It averages 4.6 stars from 2,314 reviews. £9.99, one of the cheaper options here. Have a look at the Brown GPS Dog Tracker for the full spec.
Brown
There are other options in our gps dog trackers range too.

7.Tractive Black GPS Dog Tracker
If you want the best no subscription, start here. Specs worth noting: colour Black. It averages 4.0 stars from 2,836 reviews. £51.18, so you pay a bit more for the spec. Full details, sizes and photos are on the Tractive Black GPS Dog Tracker page.
Real-time GPS Tracking
Escape & Health Alerts
Ratings a little lower than the top picks
There are other options in our gps dog trackers range too.

8.Pawfit Dog Activity Tracker
Pawfit Dog Activity Tracker is our pick for waterproof. 1,705 buyers rate it 4.2 out of 5. £54.99, so you pay a bit more for the spec. You can see the full specs and photos on the Pawfit Dog Activity Tracker page.
Fully Waterproof Activity Monitor for Dogs
Unlimited Range
Ratings a little lower than the top picks
If it is not quite right, we stock plenty more gps dog trackers.
Prefer to browse everything? Our full ranges of gps dog trackers, gps tracker collars and premium gps trackers have more sizes, finishes and price points than we could fit here.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Garmin Alpha 200 legal in England?
The handheld is a tracking device. Some Garmin collars also offer training stimulation, which cannot be used on dogs in England or Wales. Tracking-only collars are fine. Check the exact bundle you buy is tracking-only, and never use a stimulation function on a dog in England or Wales.
Do cheaper trackers work without phone signal?
Most do not. They need mobile coverage to send location. Most phone-based trackers need mobile coverage to send location. If signal drops, they report the last known position until coverage returns. It is a trade-off.
Can I track several dogs with a phone tracker?
Yes, with one tracker per dog. Each usually needs its own plan. Yes, with one tracker per dog. Each usually needs its own plan, so costs rise with more dogs. Factor that into the total.
Are there radio trackers cheaper than Garmin?
A few exist, but range and quality vary a lot. Read reviews carefully. A few exist, but range, accuracy and build quality vary a lot. Read UK reviews carefully and check the legal position on any training features.