Kind training gear, legal in every UK nation

Home / Blog / Collar or Harness for a Puppy? What UK Trainers Suggest

Comparison

Collar or Harness for a Puppy? What UK Trainers Suggest

By the Collarwise team · Updated November 2026

ContentsAt a glanceSide-by-side comparisonThe legal bitWalkingComfortFit and growthOur verdictFAQs

New puppy owners hear conflicting advice on this one. Some say a collar is all a puppy needs. Others say a harness is a must. The truth is that most puppies benefit from both, each doing a different job. So what is the best choice for your new puppy? Let us clear it up. It can be confusing. Here is our take.

This guide compares the two for a young dog: what each is good for, how they affect lead training and what UK law says about ID. We also cover fit, growth and how to introduce each so your puppy is happy to wear them from the first week. We keep it simple and practical, so you can make a choice and get on with enjoying your puppy.

At a glance

Puppy collar

TagMe Reflective 30cm Reflective Dog CollarHEELE Dog 30cm Green Puppy CollarReflective Pink Puppy Collar

Popular choices include the TagMe Reflective 30cm Reflective Dog Collar (£4.99), HEELE Dog 30cm Green Puppy Collar (£8.99) and Reflective Pink Puppy Collar (£4.87).

See the whole puppy collars range.

Puppy harness

Dog Harness Mesh Black Puppy HarnessDog Harness Mesh Puppy HarnessNo-Pull Puppy Harness

Popular choices include the Dog Harness Mesh Black Puppy Harness (£10.49), Dog Harness Mesh Puppy Harness (£10.49) and No-Pull Puppy Harness (£11.49).

See the whole puppy harnesses range.

Side-by-side comparison

FeaturePuppy collarPuppy harness
Holds ID tagYesSome do
Pressure if pullingOn throatAcross chest
Getting used to itQuickA little longer
Wear indoorsOften, light collarUsually off
Lead walkingFine for calm pupsBetter for pullers
GrowthAdjust oftenAdjust often

Once your puppy is in public, the law requires a collar with your name and address. So every puppy needs a collar or tag of some kind, whatever you walk them on. Most owners use a light collar with an engraved tag. Microchipping is also a legal requirement by eight weeks old. Keep the details on the database up to date if you move. It is the law. It takes minutes to sort.

Walking

Puppies bounce, pull and spin. A harness keeps any pressure off the delicate throat. Many trainers clip the lead to a light Y-front harness for walks. Collars can put pressure on the throat when a puppy pulls or lunges, which is common in the early months. A harness spreads that pressure across the chest. Many trainers suggest a harness for walks while the collar holds the ID tag. It is a gentle start.

Comfort

Most puppies accept a collar in minutes. A harness takes a few more treats. Introduce it slowly and never force it over the head. Most puppies accept a collar quickly. A harness takes a little more time because it goes over the head and around the body. Use treats and keep sessions short, and never force it on. A little patience now saves fuss later on. Plenty of praise helps a lot.

Fit and growth

Check both weekly. A puppy can outgrow kit in days. Two fingers under every strap is the rule. Puppies grow fast, so check the fit of both every week. You should be able to slide two fingers under every strap. Expect to buy a new size or two in the first year, especially with large breeds. Write the sizes down. Keep the old ones for spares or pass them on to a friend.

Our verdict

Use a light collar for the ID tag and a soft harness for walks.

As your puppy learns to walk on a loose lead, you can decide which you prefer for adult life.

Prefer to browse everything? Our full ranges of puppy collars and puppy harnesses have more sizes, finishes and price points than we could fit here.

Frequently asked questions

Can a puppy wear a harness all day?

It is better to take it off at home so it does not rub. It is better to take it off at home so the straps do not rub and the coat can breathe. Put it on for walks.

When should I put a collar on my puppy?

From the day they come home, with plenty of treats. From the day they come home. Start with short spells and plenty of treats, and keep the collar light and soft. Most puppies adapt within a day.

Will a harness encourage pulling?

Back clip harnesses can, so teach loose lead walking from the start or try a front clip. Back clip harnesses can make pulling easier for the dog. Teach loose lead walking from the start, or try a front clip harness.

What about crate time?

Remove the harness and consider a breakaway collar. Remove the harness before crate time, and consider a breakaway collar so there is nothing that could catch on the crate bars. A bare neck is safest in a crate.