Contents
About the Acme 211.5 Gundog WhistleAlternatives at a glanceFixed pitchMaterialLanyardDifferent pitchesThe alternativesFAQsThe Acme 211.5 is probably the most common gundog whistle in Britain. It is made in Birmingham, costs very little and has a clear, high note. If you want a different pitch, a pack with a lanyard or a whistle that sounds different from your training partner's, there are plenty of options. Few whistles are as well known. It is a classic.
This guide lists alternatives and explains how to pick and teach a recall whistle. We look at fixed pitch, materials, lanyards and choosing a different note from other dogs in your area. Whichever you pick, the training behind it matters far more than the brand. A whistle costs very little, so it is worth getting right. Here is how to choose.
About the Acme 211.5 Gundog Whistle
The Acme 211.5 is a plastic gundog whistle with a fixed high pitch, used widely for recall and stop whistles. Acme has made whistles in Birmingham since the nineteenth century.
Alternatives at a glance
- Dog Whistle Dog Whistle, £6.99
- Professional Black Training Clicker, £3.90 save about £6.10
- ACME Black Dog Whistle, 576, £4.66 save about £5.34
- Gundog Whistle, £5.99
- Dog Whistle, Train Two Dogs, £4.40 save about £5.60
- COMPANY Dog Whistle, £4.57 save about £5.43
- LUPO Dog Dog Whistle, £5.99
Fixed pitch
Choose a whistle with a stated pitch so you can buy an identical spare. A whistle with a stated pitch means you can buy an identical spare and know your dog will hear the same note. Adjustable whistles can drift, which can confuse a dog that has learned one sound. Keep a spare in the car and another by the door, so you are never caught without it. Consistency is everything.
Material
Plastic does not freeze to lips in winter. Metal looks smart but gets cold. Plastic whistles stay comfortable in cold weather and do not freeze to your lips. Metal whistles look traditional and last well but can be chilly in winter. Horn whistles are another classic choice for field work. Choose what feels comfortable, as you will be blowing it often and in all weathers. Pick whatever feels best to you.
Lanyard
A lanyard keeps the whistle to hand. A lanyard keeps your whistle round your neck and ready to use. Without one, it ends up in the wrong pocket or on the kitchen table. Some lanyards have room for two whistles, which suits owners who use one for recall and one for stop. Pick a bright one so it is easy to find. It is a cheap and useful extra. It costs very little.
Different pitches
If another dog in your group uses 211.5, try a different pitch to avoid confusion. If you walk or train with others who also use a 211.5, try a different pitch so your dogs do not respond to each other's whistles. Many gundog trainers deliberately choose different pitches for this reason. Ask around your local walking group or club before you buy. It saves confusion at busy group walks and training days.
The alternatives

1.Dog Whistle Dog Whistle
This is the one we would point most people to for closest match. Specs worth noting: pack 2 Pack. It averages 4.2 stars from 2,006 reviews. £6.99, so you pay a bit more for the spec. Have a look at the Dog Whistle Dog Whistle for the full spec.
Ratings a little lower than the top picks
There are other options in our dog whistles range too.

2.Professional Black Training Clicker
Professional Black Training Clicker is our pick for value pack. Specs worth noting: colour Black. It averages 3.9 stars from 188 reviews. £3.90, one of the cheaper options here. You can see the full specs and photos on the Professional Black Training Clicker page.
There are other options in our dog whistles range too.

3.ACME Black Dog Whistle, 576
If you want the best with lanyard, start here. Specs worth noting: colour Black. 1,725 buyers rate it 4.0 out of 5. £4.66, one of the cheaper options here. Full details, sizes and photos are on the ACME Black Dog Whistle, 576 page.
Compare it with the rest of our dog whistles.

4.Gundog Whistle
This is the one we would point most people to for lower pitch. Specs worth noting: pack 2 Pcs, material Plastic. It averages 4.1 stars from 1,019 reviews. £5.99, so you pay a bit more for the spec. Have a look at the Gundog Whistle for the full spec.
There are other options in our dog whistles range too.

5.Dog Whistle, Train Two Dogs
Dog Whistle, Train Two Dogs is our pick for silent. It averages 4.2 stars from 330 reviews. £4.40, one of the cheaper options here. You can see the full specs and photos on the Dog Whistle, Train Two Dogs page.
Train Different Commands
Tough Material
Compare it with the rest of our dog whistles.

6.COMPANY Dog Whistle
If you want something for windy days, start here. 687 buyers rate it 3.4 out of 5. £4.57, one of the cheaper options here. Full details, sizes and photos are on the COMPANY Dog Whistle page.
Adjustable Frequency
Easy to Use
Compare it with the rest of our dog whistles.

7.LUPO Dog Dog Whistle
LUPO Dog Dog Whistle is our pick for budget. It averages 3.4 stars from 443 reviews. £5.99, so you pay a bit more for the spec. You can see the full specs and photos on the LUPO Dog Dog Whistle page.
Puppy Training Whistle
Dog Recall Whistle
There are other options in our dog whistles range too.
Prefer to browse everything? Our full ranges of dog whistles, gundog whistles and silent dog whistles have more sizes, finishes and price points than we could fit here.
Frequently asked questions
What does 211.5 mean?
It is the pitch. Lower numbers give a higher note. It refers to the pitch of the whistle. Lower numbers give a higher note. The number helps you buy an identical spare. It is easy to remember.
Can I switch whistles?
Yes, but retrain the new sound with treats. Yes, but retrain the new sound with treats before relying on it. Your dog needs to learn that the new note means the same thing. Take it slowly.
Are cheaper whistles as loud?
Many are. Pitch consistency matters more. Many are. Consistent pitch matters more than volume, as your dog learns to respond to a specific note. Most plastic whistles are loud enough for parks and fields. Most are.
Is a silent whistle better?
Not usually for recall. Fixed-pitch whistles are more reliable. Not usually for recall. Fixed-pitch whistles are easier to blow the same way every time, which makes them more reliable. Stick with one whistle and one pitch.